Effectiveness of Field Visit in Community Medicine: A Randomized Control Trial

Authors

  • Shridhar V Rawal Dr. M. K. Shah Medical college and Research center, Visat Gandhinagar Highway, Chandkheda

Keywords:

Community Medicine, field visit, primary health care, block randomization, Adjusted odds ratio

Abstract

Background: The community medicine is a major subject in un- dergraduate curriculum in India. Though much is said about methods and technologies to improve teaching in the subject, the scientific proof of field visits being better than class room teaching for understanding concepts like primary health care lacks. A ran- domized controlled trial, can give better idea of effectiveness of the intervention i.e. actual field visit to the heart of primary health care services-primary health center.

Method: Double- blind block randomization trial with two arm parallel design. The intervention group and control group were subjected to a semi-structured questionnaire following interven- tion. Logistic regression for Odds ratio adjusted for sex and at- tendance calculated.

Results: Crude and adjusted odds ratio highly significant in fa- vour of intervention group. However, on sub component analysis for adjusted odds ratio for both variables, data management at  PHC was having odds ratio <1. Adjusted odds were significantly high, specially for functions of medical officer and staffing pattern of PHC.

Conclusion: The randomization clearly suggests that field visit of primary health center helps students understand and realize con- cepts of primary health care better than classroom teaching. Repli- cation of such studies with larger sample size may help.

References

Medical Council of India: Gazette of India. Regulations on graduate Medical education. part III section 4. ; 17 th May,1997. p.14. Available at http://www.mciindia.org/RulesandRegulations/GraduateMedicalEducationRegulatio ns1997.aspx. Accessed March 3rd,2019.

Vydehi Institute of Medical sciences and Research center

.Department of community medicine curriculum ;2000. Available at VIMS website www.vims.ac.in/education. Ac- cessed on March 3rd, 2019.

Hogarth J. Glossary for health care terminology, Bureau Régional de l'Europe. Organisation Mondiale de la Santé; 1977:(vol.4).

World Health Organization & UNICEF. International Con- ference on Primary Health Care 1978. Alma-Ata, USSR: WHO; 1978.

Pal R, Kar S,Zaman FA, et al. Assessment of impact of small group teaching among students in community medicine. IJCM. 2012 ;37 :170-3.

Module for training of Medical officers. Ministry of Health & Family welfare. New Delhi ;1997.

PSS Sundar Rao, J. Richard. An Introduction to biostatistics. A Manual for students in Health sciences. New Delhi : Pren- tice Hall India Pvt. Limited ; 2004. p.196.

Thomas D. Koepsell, Noel S. Weiss. Epidemiological Meth- ods. Studying the occurance of illness. Oxford : Oxford Uni. Press ; 2003. P.321-322.

Kenneth F Schulz, David A Grimes .Blinding in randomized trials: hiding who got what. The Lancet. 2002;359(9307):696- 700.

K.Park.Park’s textbook of preventive & social medicine, 18th Edition, Jabalpur : Banarsidas Bhanot publishers ; 2005. p.77.

Manzoor I, Mukhtar F, Hashmi NR . Medical students' per- spective about role-plays as a teaching strategy in communi- ty medicine. J Coll Physicians Surg Pak. Apr 2012;22(4):222- 5.

Anita Nath, Gopal Ingle. From classroom to community: teaching community medicine in India. Country paper. South East asia journal of medical education. 2008; 2: No. 2.

P K Mandal , Chitra Chatterjee,G.K. Joardar, et al. Indian Journal of Preventive & Social Medicine. 2010; 41 ( 1&2) : p. 42-46.

Pradeep Kumar. Teaching community medicine to under- graduates, problems and solutions: a loud thinking. Nation- al Journal of Community Medicine. Jan – Mar 2013 ;4 (1):1-3.

Kahyo H. Educational effect of field visit in the course of preventive medicine and community health-case report of the field visit to Chikuho districts(1981-89). Japanese Journal of public health. 1996; 43(1) : p.68-74.

Martha L. Nabors, Linda Carol Edwards, R Kent Murray. Making the case for field trips: what research tells us and what site coordinators have to say.Education.2009; 129(4): 681-687.

Knapp D. Memorable Experiences of a Science Field Trip. School Science and Mathematics, 2000; 100:65–72.

Downloads

Published

2019-04-30

How to Cite

1.
Rawal SV. Effectiveness of Field Visit in Community Medicine: A Randomized Control Trial. Natl J Community Med [Internet]. 2019 Apr. 30 [cited 2024 Apr. 19];10(04):244-8. Available from: https://njcmindia.com/index.php/file/article/view/495

Issue

Section

Original Research Articles